Why Customers Switch Banks – Data-Driven Insights for Acquisition and Retention

Mar 20, 2024

In today's competitive financial landscape, understanding why customers switch banks is crucial. While high fees are often blamed, consumer feedback gathered by Brox.ai, a leading consumer intelligence platform, paints a more complex picture. By examining the true drivers of banking churn and the push and pull factors that lead customers to consider alternatives, banks can develop more effective strategies to improve retention and attract new clients.

The Interplay of Push and Pull Factors

Our research reveals that both negative experiences with current banks (push factors) and the allure of better offerings from competitors (pull factors) contribute to churn.

"I'm thinking of switching to Capital One. I'm using Green Dot right now and it's only an online banking service and Capital One actually has a location that I can go to. So I think Capital One is what I'm switching to and that's really my reason why is that they're local and they have a location." - Male, 18-29

In this case, the lack of physical locations (push factor) and the appeal of Capital One's local presence (pull factor) combine to drive the decision to switch.

Breaking the influential factors down, we see that 58% of moves in consumer finance are driven by pull factors compared to 42% which are driven by push factors. While consumers often have complaints about their bank, many need a pull factor to really drive them to take action and move to a different bank.

Push Factors: The Negative Experiences that Drive Customers Away

Excessive or unclear fees can be a major turnoff for customers, creating distrust and dissatisfaction. A female consumer shares her experience with Wells Fargo:

"Really the only reason I'm thinking of changing banks is Wells Fargo likes to charge me money for keeping my money in the bank. And it's not like it's a whole lot that they're holding on to." - Female, 30-44

Brox.ai data consistently reveals that a lack of fee transparency is a significant pain point, particularly for younger demographics. Additionally, negative customer service experiences can be a significant push factor, especially for male customers:

"I'm no longer happy with the bank that I am at in Wells Fargo. They have just been charging me fee after fee every month and I'm tired of it. So I'm thinking of going into the branch and just closing my account and heading down to Navy Federal Credit Union." - Male, 30-44

Pull Factors: The Incentives and Experiences Luring Customers to Switch

Attractive incentives, such as sign-up bonuses, can be powerful motivators for customers to switch banks. The same female consumer highlights the appeal of Chase's offer:

"Whereas Chase, why I would consider changing to Chase is they want to pay me money to transfer my account. I like that. That works well for me." - Female, 30-44

Convenience and accessibility also play a significant role in the decision-making process, particularly for working professionals. A female consumer, aged 18-29, considers switching to PNC Bank for this reason:

"So I've actually been thinking about switching from Huntington to PNC Bank and that is just because where I work they go through PNC Bank and so I just feel that it would be a lot easier because there's an actual bank right inside of where I work." - Female, 18-29

Gender Differences in Banking Preferences

Brox.ai analysis reveals intriguing distinctions between men and women when it comes to banking preferences and churn drivers.

Women are more likely to be drawn to banks with convenient locations and robust online banking options. As the female consumer mentioned earlier:

"Basically just convenience to be honest. Anytime I need something I can do my banking right where I work which is super convenient." - Female, 18-29

Meanwhile, men are 25% more likely to switch banks due to push factors, such as excessive fees or poor service. The male consumer, aged 30-44, who expressed his frustration with Wells Fargo and intention to switch to Navy Federal Credit Union, exemplifies this trend.

Actionable Insights for Banks

By understanding these nuances, banks can adopt strategies that improve customer retention and acquisition:

Prioritize Transparency: Develop transparent and competitive fee structures that meet customer expectations.
Invest in Customer Service: Address negative service experiences by training and supporting staff to deliver exceptional customer interactions.
Craft Strategic Incentives: Offer targeted incentives and promotions, informed by Brox.ai insights, to attract new customers and retain existing ones.
Optimize Branch Networks: Evaluate and optimize branch locations and operating hours for maximum customer convenience.
Invest in Digital Innovation: Develop and maintain user-friendly online and mobile banking platforms to cater to all customer segments.

Watch this post in Action with Catrin Williams, Head of Research:

Brands Mentioned: